Here’s the irony: an academic writes a paper that references and quotes relevant prior work, and is commended for the work. But, a journalist working on a book that quotes elements of pop culture risks a copyright infringement lawsuit if he doesn’t pay for his quotes. The fact is, “fair use” is not protected, and it can only be determined in court. Fact is, the risk of lawsuit is enough to make most authors and other content creators license work for uses that most agree should be covered by fair use.
And that’s what Chris Turner had to do when he tried to quote lyrics from Radiohead for his recent book Planet Simpson.
Chris wanted to quote lines and passages from “The Bends,” “Idioteque,” and “I Might Be Wrong,” and Warner Bros., Radiohead’s publisher, saw dollar signs. Never mind that the quotes totaled just 87 words from the three songs, WB still wanted over $4 per word. For context, Chris pointed out that the price demanded by Warner was “more than double the highest amount I’ve ever been paid per word to write for a magazine or newspaper.”
It might also be useful to point out that the book isn’t about Radiohead. It’s about The Simpsons. Did Fox TV demand payment for quotes from the TV show? Chris says no:
I was not required to fork over a single dime to quote from The Simpsons itself, nor to quote at length from Tony Hendra’s excellent book Going Too Far, nor to quote from Foucault or Mark Twain or David Foster Wallace.
ArsTechnica picked up on the story after it was reported in Copyfight, which found it on Chris’s website. Ceaser, at Ars, had this to say:
The mind blowing aspect of this is, of course, the music industry’s hubris. Why is it that I can quote hundreds and hundreds of words from academic authors who have the same copyright protections as the music industry, and yet I have to pay nothing? Why does a few dozen words of lyrics require payment?
Here’s what I have to say: the US economy depends on “the next big thing.” ™ This should be a clear example of “chilling effects” — how copyright, when wrongly practiced, limits a society’s ability to develop new works, new products, or “the next big thing.” ™
Related:
Posted November 24, 2004 by Casey
Categories: Copyrights & Intellectual Property. .
1 Comment(s)
Comments RSS
TrackBack Identifier URI
Leave a comment
User contributed tags for this post:
how to make brass knuckles (1207) - homemade brass knuckles (429) - making brass knuckles (137) - make brass knuckles (134) - cheap brass knuckles (128) - make your own brass knuckles (97) - how to make homemade brass knuckles (91) - homemade knuckles (73) - how to use brass knuckles (71) - diy brass knuckles (50) - how to make brass knuckle (42) - how to make your own brass knuckles (37) - homemade brass knuckle (37) - google planet (36) - how to make a brass knuckle (30) - brass knuckles (29) - discount brass knuckles (23) - brass knuckles homemade (18) - how to build brass knuckles (16) - how to make brass knuckles at home (16) - how do you make brass knuckles (16) - how to make knuckles (15) - how to make brass (15) - home made knuckles (14) - brass knuckles law (14) - make homemade brass knuckles (13) - how to make a brass knuckles (13) - brass knuckles how to make (13) - cheapest brass knuckles (12) - brass knuckles make your own (11) - Home made brass knuckles (11) - how to make brassknuckles (11) - make brass knuckle (11) - make a brass knuckle (10) - all (9) - making knuckles (9) - brass knuckles cheap (9) - making brass knuckle (9) - how to make homemade knuckles (9) - how 2 make brass knuckles (8) - brass knuckles tutorial (8) - how do you use brass knuckles (8) - make your own brass knuckle (8) - Home Made Brass Knuckle (7) - brass knuckle making (7) - Build Brass Knuckles (7) - how homemade knuckles (7) - brass knuckle quotes (7) - timothy treadwell quotes (7) - brass knuckles diy (7) - mss (7) - quotes (6) - brass knuckles make (6) - how to make brass knucks (6) - cheap brass knuckle (6) - how to make home made brass knuckles (6) - making your own brass knuckles (6) - brass knuckle use (6) - google planet earth (5) - brass knuckles making (5) - brass knuckle homemade (5) - Making Homemade Brass Knuckles (5) - how to make cheap brass knuckles (5) - homemade knuckle (5) - how to use brass knuckle (5) - cheap brassknuckles (5) - brass knuckle (5) - how to build knuckles (5) - how can i build a brass knuckle (5) - how to make brass nuckles (5) - how to make knuckle (4) - homemade brass knuckles tutorial (4) - homemade brass nuckles (4) - how to make your own homemade brass knuckles (4) - Chris Turner blog (4) - homemade brass knuckles mac (4) - how to brass knuckles (4) - Brass Knuckle how to make (4) - nevada brass knuckle laws (4) - how made Brass Knuckles (4) - how to make home made knuckles (4) - how can i make brass knuckles at home (4) - how brass knuckles work (4) - Big 5 brass knuckles (4) - brass knuckles for cheap (4) - google planet earth com (4) - palmos voip (4) - wb homemade (4) - make knuckles (4) - make brass knickles (3) - brass knuckles use (3) - maisonbisson com (3) - make own brass knuckles (3) - knuckle homemade (3) - making brass knuckles at home (3) - brass knuckle cheap (3) - brass knuckle diy (3) - making cheap brass knuckles (3) - brass knuckles how to use (3) - how to make brass knucles (3) - use brass knuckles (3) - how to make your own brass knuckles at home (3) - brass knuckles newspaper how to make (3) - google maps (2) - making knuckles brass (2) - the uses of brass knuckles (2) - Brass knuckles made of newspaper (2) - brass knuckles LAWS (2) - how make brass knuckles (2) - build a brass knuckles (2) - making brass knuckles mac (2) - diy knuckles (2) - how to do brass knuckles (2) - make my own brass knuckle (2) - how to make a brassknuckle (2) - nevada law brass knuckles (2) - brass knuckle law (2) - brass knuckle laws in nevada (2) - how to do brass knuckles making (2) - Brass Nuckles pay (2) - make your own brass knucks (2) - HOW TO MAKE BRASS KUCKLES (2) - How Do I Make My Own Brass Knuckles (2) - how make brassknuckles (2) - making brass (2) - 7 oz brass knuckles (2) - brass knuckles d i y (2) - making brass knuckels (2) - cheap brassknuckle (2) - volvo ipod (2) - how to make brass knuckles weapon (2) - brass knuckle laws (2) - make your own (2) - build own brass knuckles (2) - make your own brassknuckle (2) - earth com (2) - how to make brass knuckles tutorial (2) - brass knuckles how to made (2) - brass knuckle tutorial (2) - radiohead quotes (2) - brass knuckle law in nevada (2) - brass knuckles howto (2) - make your own brassknuckles (2) - build brass knuckle (2) - chris turner blog simpsons (2) - making of brass knuckles (2) - building your own brass knuckles (2) - tony hendra blog trackback (2) - how to make your own brass knuckle (2) - use brass knuckle (2) -
[...] 400 or so words would cost $400, which isn’t as bad as $400 for 87 words, but [...]